Ashok MishraThe images of the Yamuna during the Chhath festival have once again shaken the entire nation. During Chhath—one of the most sacred festivals of faith—devotees were compelled to stand in a river covered by a thick layer of toxic white foam. Photographs from the riverbanks in Delhi and Noida showed people submerged waist-deep in filthy water, with children and the elderly wading through the foam. Holding *thekua* (a traditional offering) and *soop* (bamboo trays) to offer to the Sun God, devotees were forced to come into contact with water that is not only unsafe to drink but hazardous even to touch. This was not a sudden disaster; rather, it is the consequence of decades of neglect, incomplete projects, and cleanup initiatives that exist only on paper—despite the massive sums of money already spent. Against this backdrop, the Supreme Court, in an order dated November 4 (made public on November 16), issued a stern observation: despite the enormous expenditure, pollution in the Yamuna is increasing rather than decreasing.
A bench comprising Justices Manoj Mishra and Manmohan remarked that the poor state of the Yamuna clearly reflects the failures of the civic administration in the towns, cities, and villages situated along its banks. This is precisely why, despite such heavy spending, the river has only become more polluted. The court specifically highlighted the 520 drains that discharge untreated sewage and industrial waste directly into the Yamuna. According to one report, over 8,000 crore rupees have been spent on cleaning the Yamuna since 1993—yet the river remains severely polluted. In this context, the central government has formulated a 'National Action Plan' for the cleaning of the Yamuna, involving an investment of over ₹18,600 crore—an initiative developed following a Supreme Court order dated May 21, 2026. Furthermore, on October 22, 2026, 43 projects under the Delhi Jal Board were inaugurated or saw their foundation stones laid, with a total estimated cost of approximately ₹8,941.22 crore. The primary objective of these efforts is the complete rejuvenation of the river by May 2029.
The question arises: given the scale of these plans, the massive budgets involved, and the repeated setting of deadlines, why does the surface of the Yamuna remain covered in foam during the festival of Chhath? Why is the stretch of the Yamuna that flows through Delhi considered one of the most polluted river segments in the country? The root cause of the Yamuna’s pollution is domestic sewage—a fact now acknowledged even within the draft 'Yamuna Action Plan' submitted to the Supreme Court. While the Court noted that this plan represents a step forward by identifying domestic sewage as the primary pollutant, it also contains significant contradictions. For instance, while the draft claims that water bodies and wetlands in Delhi’s 'Zone O' are free from encroachment, an annexure provided by the Delhi government itself indicates that all 35 water bodies in that zone have been encroached upon. Similarly, while it is claimed that 28 out of Delhi’s 37 sewage treatment plants meet the required standards, a report by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) reveals that not a single plant complies with all the prescribed criteria. These contradictions encapsulate the entire narrative of the Yamuna cleaning efforts: on paper, plants appear operational and reports show progress, yet there is no discernible improvement in the quality of the river water.
This time, the Supreme Court has not merely expressed its displeasure; it has established a clear and stringent framework for accountability. The Court has ruled that if the water quality of the Yamuna deteriorates—by any standard—while passing through or exiting any state, union territory, or district, that specific jurisdiction will be held responsible and subjected to a fine. This fine must be deposited directly into the Supreme Court’s registry. Consequently, no state or district will be able to evade responsibility by claiming that the pollution originates upstream. Henceforth, water quality will be monitored at every administrative boundary; it will be recorded what the water’s condition was upon entering a territory and how it changed by the time it exited.
To implement this, the Court has directed the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to maintain regular surveillance of the water quality in the Yamuna and its major drains, and to collect samples at the entry and exit points of every state, union territory, and district. These samples will undergo independent analysis by institutions such as IITs, NITs, or other accredited laboratories, and a formula will be devised to calculate the applicable fines. The pollution of the Yamuna serves as a stark warning, highlighting the profound chasm between a culture that reveres the river as a goddess and a governance system that treats it as a mere sewer. When devotees, driven by faith, immerse themselves in water that is scientifically deemed unfit even for bathing, the issue transcends environmental concerns—it becomes a matter of public health, social justice, and the credibility of governance.

