Thursday, November 19, 2026

In UP, the real battle will be fought at the polling booths, not through speeches


Ashok Mishra

Assembly elections are set to take place in Uttar Pradesh in two months. Just ahead of these polls, a controversy has erupted over the electoral rolls. The electoral roll is no longer merely an administrative document; it has become a major political issue. This controversy stems from a claim made by Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, who asserts that following a 'Special Intensive Revision' (SIR), the names of approximately 12.7 million (1.27 crore) Hindu voters have gone missing from the state's assembly electoral rolls, while the number of Muslim voters has increased by 1.65 percent. To support his claim, the Chief Minister has presented three sets of figures: first, that about 6.6 million (66 lakh) individuals listed in the panchayat election rolls are absent from the assembly electoral rolls; second, that approximately 5.5 million (55 lakh) Hindu beneficiaries of government welfare schemes are missing from the list; and third, that about 450,000 (4.5 lakh) young voters aged 18–19 are also not reflected in the rolls. Based on this, the state government has submitted a memorandum to the Election Commission, demanding a review. 

This claim has shaken electoral equations on multiple levels. If these figures are accurate, it directly impacts the BJP’s core vote bank—a base the party relies upon for victory, anchored in Hindutva, welfare schemes, and the support of young voters. Conversely, if the figures are incorrect, it provides the opposition with an opportunity to argue that the ruling party itself is sowing confusion regarding the Election Commission and the electoral rolls. The Election Commission has responded to this claim with clarity and in technical terms. The Chief Electoral Officer of Uttar Pradesh has stated that the Commission does not maintain data on the religion or caste of voters; the electoral rolls contain only names, relationships, age, date of birth, and house numbers. Therefore, any claim regarding the addition or deletion of voters from a specific community based on religion cannot be verified using the Commission’s own data. 

The Commission has also stated that, following the Special Intensive Revision (SIR), 1,884,113 new voters have been added to the draft electoral roll released on November 17. The total number of voters has reached 135,868,905, and a period from November 17 to December 16 has been provided for filing claims and objections. The final roll will be published in January 2027; this means the current list is not yet final, and the legal avenues for adding, removing, or correcting names—via Forms 6, 7, and 8—remain open. Despite this clarification from the Commission, the discrepancy between the two types of electoral rolls has become a significant technical issue. Panchayat electoral rolls are prepared by the State Election Commission, while those for the Legislative Assembly and the Lok Sabha are prepared by the Election Commission of India. Because they differ in their foundational criteria, cut-off dates, address verification processes, and methods for accounting for migrant voters, the presence of a name on one list does not guarantee its inclusion on the other. 

This discrepancy has now become a subject of political debate. A second dimension to this debate has emerged within the BJP itself. Contrary to the Chief Minister’s claims, Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya stated that no voter’s name has been removed and that everyone remains on the list. This suggests a lack of consensus within the party regarding the electoral roll. One faction views the potential exclusion of Hindu voters as a serious oversight, while another seeks to downplay the controversy by framing it as a routine administrative procedure. A third dimension has been introduced by the opposition; Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav has questioned the Chief Minister, asking: if the Election Commission does not maintain data based on religion, then where did the figure of 12.7 million (1.27 crore) "missing" Hindu voters originate? 

He has further alleged that the BJP is attempting to add fraudulent voters using Form 6, while potentially orchestrating the removal of names belonging to SP workers and opposition supporters. Akhilesh has also turned Yogi’s old ‘80:20’ formula on its head, quipping that the BJP alliance might end up restricted to just 80 seats this time. This suggests that the Samajwadi Party (SP) intends to frame this issue not merely as a technical error in the electoral rolls, but as evidence of the BJP’s fear of defeat and its misuse of power. The final—and most critical—equation is the trust of the public. Questions surrounding the electoral rolls may lead voters to wonder whether their names are even included, or if their votes will actually be cast. 

Such uncertainty could significantly influence voter turnout. Consequently, the real battle over the next two months will be fought less through speeches and more at the polling booths; party workers will go door-to-door to verify names, assist with forms, file objections, and ensure that their supporters reach the polling stations. Ultimately, the outcome will not be determined by the scale of the claims made, but by which party succeeds in securing its voters' names on the rolls during the claims-and-objections process (ending December 16) and, crucially, which party manages to get its voters to leave their homes and reach the polling booths on election day.

No comments:

Post a Comment